FEBRUARY 2011

PROCUREMENT COMMUNICATIONS REPORT

 

OAG employees must document all written and oral communications they receive that impart or request material information or make a material argument regarding potential action concerning a procurement matter, including but not limited to an application, a contract, or a project.  This requirement does not apply to communications regarding the administration and implementation of an existing contract, except communications regarding change orders or the renewal or extension of a contract.

 

 

Name and

Title OAG

Employee

Date/time of contact

Name and title of

 person making

 contact and name of company they

 represent

Registered

Lobbyist?

Name and title

of each

additional

participant to

the

communication

 

Method of contact (oral by phone, oral in person, or in writing).  If by phone, list each person's phone number.  If in person, list location of meeting. 

Approximate

duration of

communication.

Provide a detailed summary of the points made by each person involved in the communication, including any action requested or  recommendation made, and the substance of your response.

Jose G. Roa

Auditor III

2/1/2011

11:20 am

Scott Bailey, Dir. Risk & Advisory, Bronner Group, LLC

No

None

Scott Bailey P: (312) 759-5101

Jose G. Roa P: (312) 814-4008

5 minutes

Scott stated firm is interested in performing Criminal Justice Information Authority compliance examination for the two years ended 6/30/11 and the firm is still independent with no potential conflict of interest.  I informed him welcome letter with engagement information will be forthcoming in the future. 

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-3-11

1:27am

Jeff Bonick, Partner

Clifton Gunderson & Co.

No

None

Jeff Bonick 309-495-8731

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

3 minutes

Follow-up on Procurement Question on 1/28/11 pertaining to RFP 11-4 pertaining to Illinois State University. At this time Clifiton Gunderson is precluded from proposing on RFP 11-4 since they are the predecessor audit firm acting as Special Assistant Auditors for the OAG. However, if the OAG does not receive proposals in response to the RFP 11-4 or the proposal(s) received are not satisfactory the OAG will reevaluate at that time.

Jon Fox,

Auditor V

2-7-11

10:40am

Chris Meister, Executive Director, Illinois Finance Authority (IFA)

No

None

Chris Meister 312-651-1310

Jon Fox 217-524-2149

2 minutes

Chris asked how many respondents we had to last year’s RFP for the IFA audit engagement.  He was concerned about the potential negative impact the prior administration might have had on interest in last year’s RFP.  I responded by e-mail that three audit firms had proposed on the IFA RFP.  I also indicated to Chris that it was my opinion that it would not have had an impact because it was over six years ago.       

Kathy Lovejoy

IS V

2-4-11

3:30 pm

Janice Romack, Partner

West & Co.

No

None

Janice Romack-618-664-4848

Kathy Lovejoy-217-782-0798

5 minutes

Discussed the FY 11 ICI audit to determine the firms interest and independence.

Jon Fox

Auditor V

2-7-11 4:30pm

Chris Meister, Executive Director, Illinois Finance Authority (IFA)

No

None

In Writing

Chris Meister CMeister at il-fa.com

Jon Fox oag32 at mail.state.il.us

10 minutes

Chris e-mailed asking if there was a disclosure requirement for procurement.  This was prompted by our previous conversation today when I asked Chris if he was a registered lobbyist and why I was asking.  I returned his e-mail and referred him to our January 2011 Procurement Communications report on our website and gave him the Administrative Code citation. 

Thomas Kizziah

Auditor V

2-8-11

10:20am

Joe Evans, Partner McGladrey & Pullen

No

None

Joe Evans – 312-485-1776 (Cell Phone)

Thomas Kizziah – 312-814-4073

5 minutes

I asked Joe if he were still interested and independent on both the Illinois Housing Development Authority and the State Universities Retirement System.  He stated he was interested and independent for both of these engagements.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-8-11

11:00am

Joe Evans, Partner

Linda Abernethy, Partner

McGladrey & Pullen LLP

No

None

Meeting at the Illinois Office of the Auditor

General in Springfield, Illinois.

30 minutes

Discussed audit matters related to the current and ongoing audits of the Illinois Student Assistance Commission and the Illinois Toll Highway Authority. Discussed the RFP 11- 2 which the OAG has issued pertaining to the Illinois Student Assistance Commission. Specifically, whether McGladrey & Pullen LLP would be eligible to propose on the RFP 11- 2.  I told Mr. Evans and Mrs. Abernethy that he would research the matter and contact them by phone later today.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-8-11

1:45pm

Joe Evans, Partner

McGladrey & Pullen LLP

No

None

Joe Evans 312-485-1776 (Cell Phone)

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

1 minute

I informed Joe Evans that the firm of McGladrey and Pullen LLP is eligible to submit a proposal in response to the OAG RFP 11-2 pertaining to the FY 11 audit of the Illinois Student Assistance Commission. Further, the OAG would post an amendment on its web-site today stating - The Office of the Auditor General is not precluding the public accounting firm (special assistant auditors) that is currently contracted and performing the fiscal year 2010 Illinois Student Assistance Commission engagement from submitting the proposals described in this solicitation.

Candice Long

Audit Manager

2-9-11

10:47am

Linda Abernethy, Partner McGladrey & Pullen, LLP

No

None

TO:  Linda email: Linda.abernethy-at-mcgladrey.com

From:  CL email: oag40-at-mail.state.il.us

n/a

Emailed Linda a revised timetable for the Department of Revenue engagement with changes reflected.

Candice Long

Audit Manager

2-9-11

11:15 am

Linda Abernethy, Partner McGladrey & Pullen, LLP

No

None

Linda Abernethy 847-413-6248

Candice Long 217-524-5450

5 minutes

We discussed the changes in the engagement timetable for the Department of Revenue Engagement and decided to proceed with the revised dates and complete an amendment.  I told Linda I would overnight the contract amendment to her.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-14-10

8:45am

Troy Swinford

Partner, BKD

 

No

None

Troy Swinford 217-429-8411

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

4 minutes

BKD e-mailed a question regarding RFP 11-1 pertaining to the Illinois State Board of Education. “We just had a couple of questions as we were working through the proposal process. Did something change in the last 2 years of the engagement – specifically related to the GAAP packages? Was the firm preparing them as well? We just noticed the hours increasing in 2009/2010 and it appeared to be related to GAAP packages.” Answer: Yes, The increase in hours is primarily attributed to a conversion process. The scope of the FY 08 the engagement was a one year financial audit, one year State Compliance Examination, and Agreed Upon Procedures Work. The scope of the FY 09 the engagement was a one year financial audit and agreed upon procedures work. The actual hours incurred were significantly higher than the original estimate. The scope of the FY 10 the engagement was a one year financial audit, two year State Compliance Examination, and Agreed Upon Procedures work. A final billing has not yet been received for this engagement.  The firm (special assistant auditors) did not prepare the GAAP packages for the Illinois State Board of Education. I suggested that BKD take a close look at page 2a, 10, and 11 of the RFP.

Teresa Davis

Audit Manager

2-14-11

10:15 am

Gary Neubauer,

Partner, Sikich, LLP

No

None

Gary Neubauer (217) 862-1710

Teresa Davis (217) 782-0818

5 minutes

Discussed amending the contract timetable for the Department of Central Management Services due to delays in the engagement.  Gary will submit revised timetable.

Candice Long

Audit Manager

2/14/11 in mail

Tom Leach, Partner with Sikich, LLP

No

None

Tom Leach, 132 S. Water St., Suite 300

Decatur, IL 62523

N/A

Received signed contract amendment for IOC Nonfiscal Officer engagement FY10

Candice Long

Audit Manager

2/14/11 in mail

Linda Abernethy, Partner with McGladrey & Pullen, LLP

No

None

Linda Abernethy, 20 N. Martingale rd.., Schaumburg, IL 60173

N/A

Received signed contract amendment for IDOR FY10 engagement

Teresa Davis

Audit Manager

2-15-11

9:07 am

Gary Neubauer,

Partner, Sikich, LLP

No

None

E-mail

From:  Gary Neubauer GNeubauer-at-Sickick.com

TO: Teresa Davis  OAG28-at-mail.state.il .us

N/A

Gary e-mailed the suggested revisions to the Central Management Services contract timetable.

Teresa Davis

Audit Manager

2-15-11

9:16 am

Gary Neubauer,

Partner, Sikich, LLP

No

None

E-mail

To:  Gary Neubauer GNeubauer-at-Sickick.com

From: Teresa Davis  OAG28-at-mail.state.il .us

N/A

Gary previously e-mailed the suggested revisions to the Central Management Services contract timetable and audit manager e-mailed back to state that the revisions to the contract timetable was reasonable.

Jane Clark

Statewide Single Audit Manager

2-15-11

3:20 p.m.

Cathy Baumann,

Partner, KPMG LLP

No

None

Meeting at the Illinois Office of the Auditor

General in Springfield, Illinois.

5 minutes

Discussed amending contract timetable for the Statewide Single Audit as well as for the decrease in the number of major programs to be audited based on final SEFA information received from the IOC.  Cathy will submit revised budget and timetable in the near future for my review.

Lisa Warden Audit Manager

2-16-11

10:41 am

Nick Appelbaum

Partner, Sikich LLP

No

None

Nick Appelbaum  217-793-3363

Lisa Warden  217-785-2683

5 minutes

Discussed firm’s interest, independence, and lack of conflicts of interest to conduct the FY10/11 repeat compliance examination of Department of Public Health.  An information systems review of the Department will be the subject of a separate contract.  I will send a welcome letter and background information and the firm will prepare an informal proposal.  Expenses should be included in the computed rate.

Lisa Warden Audit Manager

2-16-11

4:38 pm

Ed Ortiz

Principal,

EC Ortiz & Co., LLP

No

None

Ed Ortiz 1-312-876-1900

Lisa Warden  217-785-2683

3 minutes

Discussed firm’s interest, independence, and lack of conflicts of interest to conduct the FY11 repeat financial/compliance/Single audit of Western Illinois University.  Firm will send an informal proposal after the FY10 audit is complete.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-16-11

4:37 pm

Cheryl Martin

Partner

KEB

No

None

Cheryl Martin 217-789-0960

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

4 minutes

Cheryl Martin asked about RFP 11-3, page 8, Item 3 pertaining to Required/Preferred Experience. Specifically, the requirement pertaining to Entities which issue bonds and have outstanding bonded debt of $1 billion or more. Was this a requirement in the last RFP issued by the OAG for the Office of the Treasurer audit engagement? Answer: Yes, however, the requirement was for $500 million. OAG thought the amount should be raised for this RFP procurement. Firms proposing should address their prior experience concerning this requirement.

Teresa Davis

Audit Manager

2-15-11

3:15 pm

Gary Neubauer,

Partner, Sikich, LLP

No

None

In writing

N/A

Teresa received in writing a revised Central Management Services contract timetable from Gary Neubauer.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-18-11

9:20am

Joe Evans

Partner

McGladrey & Pullen LLP

No

None

Joe Evans 847-413-6919

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

3 minutes

Mr. Evans called concerning the new disclosure forms included in the OAG RFP (specifically information requirements addressed pages 33,   34 and 35). Subsection 1a on pages 33 and 34 contain three different boxes. McGladrey and Pullen LLP would meet the definition in the second box; however, they are also a partnership referenced in the box 3. However, the first sentence after box 3 makes a specific reference to “or any other entity not covered above.” In the past, McGladrey & Pullen LLP has provided a listing of all partners, performed specific due diligence with all firm partners and addressed information requirements set forth in Subsection 1b of the disclosure form. Prior to proceeding with the completion of the disclosure form and conflicts of interest, however,  Mr. Evans wanted to check with the OAG regarding expectations since their appears to be some inconsistency between  Subsection 1a for box 2 and 3 as it would apply to the firm of McGladrey and Pullen. I responded that I would research the matter and get back to him this morning.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-18-11

9:45am

Joe Evans

Partner

McGladrey & Pullen LLP

No

None

Joe Evans 847-413-6919

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

2 minutes

I called Joe Evans back after performing certain research related to his questions from earlier in the morning. I told Mr. Evans that the OAG understood his questions regarding the disclosures on pages 33, 34, and 35. With regard to Subsection 1a it would be fine to check both the 2 and 3rd box in McGladrey & Pullen’s situation. The second box refers to 17 CFR 229.401 which would likely be a very specific list of individuals. Box number 3 would require a listing of all partners.  Subsection 1b would be addressed for the list of any individuals identified in Subsection 1a. Thus, the firm of McGladrey and Pullen LLP should perform its due diligence in completing the disclosure forms and conflicts of interest for all individuals listed in Subsection 1a when responding to matters set forth in Subsection 1b.

Jane Clark

Statewide Single Audit

Manager

2-18-11

11:45

Kyle McGinnis

Sole Proprietor

 

No

None

Jane Clark 217-782-0816

Kyle McGinnis 217-753-3377

3 minutes

Discussed firm’s interest, independence, and lack of conflict of interest to conduct the audit of the Illinois Conservation Foundation for the year ended June 30, 2011.  This will be their last rotation on this engagement.  Discussed that expenses should be incorporated into their fee structure when they submit their proposal.  I will be sending the welcome letter in the near future and then he will need to prepare the informal proposal and submit for my review. 

Jane Clark

Statewide Single Audit

Manager

2-18-11

11:50

Kyle McGinnis

Sole Proprietor

 

No

None

Jane Clark 217-782-0816

Kyle McGinnis 217-753-3377

3 minutes

Discussed firm’s interest, independence, and lack of conflict of interest to conduct the audit of the Illinois Board of Admissions to the Bar for the two years ended September 30, 2011.  This will be their last rotation on this engagement (emergency procurement last time).  Discussed that expenses should be incorporated into their fee structure when they submit their proposal.  I will be sending the welcome letter in the near future and then he will need to prepare the informal proposal and submit for my review. 

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-18-11

11:15am

Tom McGreal

Partner

McGreal & Company PC

No

None

Tom McGreal 708-422-8600

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

3 minutes

Mr. McGreal called this morning regarding the upcoming FY 11 engagements. Specifically, Mr. McGreal indicated his firm is giving some consideration to proposing on an OAG RFP that has been recently issued. McGreal & Company PC, however, has not completed their rotation cycle with the OAG for two other OAG engagements scheduled to be performed this calendar year. Further, McGreal & Company PC had not yet been contacted by an OAG employee about their interest or independence for one of the two engagements for the upcoming audit cycle where the firm rotation cycle had not yet been completed.  Specifically, McGreal & Company PC was wondering if the OAG has made other plans for this engagement which impacts their decision process related to OAG RFPs currently on the street.  I apologized to Mr. McGreal that he had not yet been contacted and that the OAG employee assigned to do this would be contacting him next week. 

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-18-11

12:50pm

Jeff Dowd

Principal

Reznick Group PC

No

None

Jeff Dowd 847-324-7514

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

3 minutes

Mr. Dowd requested information on how to locate prior audit reports the OAG has issued related to the entities covered in  RFP 11-2 (ISAC) and 11-3 (Office of the State Treasurer). I walked him through the OAG web-site to locate prior reports that have been issued.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-18-11

4:30pm

Jeff Markert

Partner

KPMG

No

None

Jeff Markert 312-399-5850

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0809

3 minutes

Mr. Markert made a general inquiry regarding the disclosure forms in the OAG RFP documents on the street. Specifically, whether the disclosure forms had changed from the ones the OAG used last year.  I responded that the format has been modified; however, the basic content has not changed. Mr. Markert asked if the list of partners in subsection (a) should include those outside the U S. I responded that I would research the matter call him back.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-18-11

4:38pm

 

Jeff Markert

Partner

KPMG

No

None

Jeff Markert 312-399-5850

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0809

2 minutes

I called Mr. Market back to follow up on our discussion. Specifically, I indicated the law and the forms are silent on the matter of disclosing partners on a world wide basis. Mr. Market indicted that the international partners were part of a separate legal entity. I responded that the OAG would not reject any proposal that listed only U S partners.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-18-11

4:48pm

Jeff Markert

Partner

KPMG

No

None

Jeff Markert 312-399-5850

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0809

3 minutes

Discussion about subsection (b) items of the disclosure forms took place concerning their applicability to all geographical areas of the U. S. for all partners listed in subsection (a).

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-18-11

4:58pm

Jeff Markert

Partner

KPMG

No

None

Jeff Markert 312-399-5850

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

3 minutes

I called Mr. Markert back after reviewing all the items set forth under subsection (b) of the disclosure forms.   I indicated that I thought most of the items set forth under subsection (b), in my opinion, related to the geographical boundaries of Illinois. However, a few of the items under subsection (b) would pertain to items which are not limited to the geographical boundaries of Illinois. I indicated these items should clearly stand out when one works their way through the items under subsection (b) of the disclosure form.

Jane Clark,

Statewide Single Audit

Manager

2-22-11

9:00

Ed Ortiz

Principal,

EC Ortiz & Co., LLP

No

None

Jane Clark 217-782-0816

Ed Ortiz 312-876-1900

3 minutes

Discussed firm’s interest, independence, and lack of conflict of interest to conduct the audit of the Supreme Court (including Appellate Court Districts 1-5 and the Illinois Courts Commission) for the two years ended June 30, 2011.   Discussed that expenses should be incorporated into their fee structure when they submit their proposal.  I will be sending the welcome letter this week and then he will need to prepare the informal proposal and submit for my review by mid April as we do have a budget for early work (ie. prior to June 30).  Let him know the four disclosure forms had been consolidated into one document. 

Jane Clark,

Statewide Single Audit

Manager

2-22-11

9:05

Ed Ortiz

Principal,

EC Ortiz & Co., LLP

No

None

Jane Clark 217-782-0816

Ed Ortiz 312-876-1900

3 minutes

Discussed firm’s interest, independence, and lack of conflict of interest to conduct the audit of the Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission for the two years ended December 31, 2011.   Discussed this will be the final rotation for this engagements since it was an emergency procurement in FY09.  Discussed that expenses should be incorporated into their fee structure when they submit their proposal.  I will be sending the welcome letter this week and then he will need to prepare the informal proposal and submit for my review by mid May as my Director likes to have all contracting done prior to mid June.  There is no early work money budgeted on this engagement as it is a 12/31 year end.  

Peggy Hartson

Audit Manager

2-22-11

9:30am

Ed Ortiz

Principal,

EC Ortiz & Co., LLP

No

None

Peggy Hartson 217-524-8748

Ed Ortiz

2 minutes

Discussed the firm’s interest, independence and lack of conflict of interest to conduct the financial audit of the Environmental Protection Agency’s Water Revolving Fund for the year ended June 30, 2011.    Noted that I will be sending the welcome letter in the near future.    Discussed that the firm’s expenses will be built in to their fees when they submit their proposal.  

Peggy Hartson

Audit Manager

2-22-11

9:35am

Nick Appelbaum

Principal

Sikich LLP

No

None

Peggy Hartson 217-524-8748

Nick Appelbaum 217-793-3922

3 minutes

Discussed the firm’s interest, independence and lack of conflict of interest to conduct the financial audit of the Department of Transportation for the year ended June 30, 2011.    Noted that I will be sending the welcome letter in the near future and the firm’s expenses will be built into their fees when they submit their proposal.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-22-11

11:35am

Jeff Dowd

Principal

Reznick Group PC

No

None

Jeff Dowd 847-324-7514

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

5 minutes

Mr. Dowd inquired about making an appointment to view information available the OAG office related to RFP 11-3. I suggested he call Denise Gladney in our Chicago office at 312-814-4007 to schedule a time to view information referenced in Section 11 of the RFP document.  Mr. Dowd inquired about the approximate or historical hour information referenced on the Notice of Intent to Issue Request for Proposals related to RFP 11-3. The information for the four engagements was briefly discussed, however, I suggested to Mr. Dowd that he review past billing and supporting document information available in the OAG office related to: 1) level of effort by major audit area, 2) level of effort by class of accountant, and 3) level of effort by month for more detailed information related to past audit effort.

Lana Miari  Auditor III

2-22-11

2:05pm

Colleen Porter

Manager

McGreal & Company

No

Thomas. Kizziah

Lana Miari & Thomas L. Kizziah  312-814-4073

Collen Porter 708-422-8600

5 minutes

Lana & Thomas called Colleen to determine whether the Firm was still interested in performing the upcoming engagement of the Illinois Department of Human Rights and to determine if the Firm was still independent.  Colleen stated yes to both questions.  Lana & Thomas informed Colleen that our Office no longer pays expenses as part of the contract.  These expenses will need to be built into the hourly fee going forward.  Lana & Thomas also informed Colleen that an Agency notification letter would go out in approximately 6 weeks and that the Welcome Letter with all necessary contract forms would be enclosed. 

Thomas Kizziah Auditor V

2-22-11

2:10pm

Edilberto Ortiz, Partner  -  E.C. Ortiz & Co., LLP

No

None

Face to Face in the Chicago Office of the Auditor General

5 minutes

Edilberto was in the Chicago Office reviewing an RFP.  I met with him to ask if he was still interested in performing the engagements on the Illinois Department of Employment Security, Governors State University, Illinois Medical District Commission and Workers Compensation Self Insurers Fund.  Edilberto stated he was interested and I asked him if he was still independent in relation to those engagements.  He stated that he was still independent.  I told him that I would be sending him the Welcome Letters on these engagements in the next 6 weeks or so and that the Letters would provide him with his Phase I dollar threshold and all of the necessary forms in order to send me a proposal.

Elena Bryjka

Auditor III

2-22-11

2:34 p.m.

Mike Morrissey

Manager

McGreal and Company PC

No

None

Email:

To: Mike Morrissey <mikem-at-mcgreal.com>

From: EVB <oag21-at-mail.state.il.us>

n/a

Mike contacted me regarding the number of hours that were budgeted for both Phase I work (to be performed prior to June 30, 2011) and Phase II work.  I told him that we are not allowed to disclose that type of information but was able to relate the early work budget in dollars.  In addition, I reiterated that the welcome letter would be forthcoming, which should assist him in developing a proposal.

Bruce Bullard

Director

2-23-11

11:26am

Jeff Bonick

Partner

Clifton Gunderson & C0.

No

None

Jeff Bonick 309-495-8731

Bruce Bullard 217-782-0811

5 minutes

Jeff Bonick called and indicated that Clifton Gunderson & Co. was taking a careful look at RFP 11-3 pertaining to the Office of the Treasurer engagement. However, in performing their due diligence in preparing a proposal a matter came to their attention that he wanted to discuss. The Office of the Treasurer engagement is made up of 4 separate audits: 1) Fiscal Officer, 2) Non Fiscal Officer, 3) Illinois Funds, and 4) College Savings Program. The College Savings Program engagement pertains to a 529 Plan. Specifically, one of the partners in the Peoria office of Clifton Gunderson & Co. has a family and contributes to the 529 Plan for a family member. In reading the AICPA’s Code of Professional Conduct pertaining to independence, integrity, and objectivity one specific section 17 101.15 addresses independence matters related to Section 529 Plans. One of the partners in the Peoria Office of Clifton Gunderson would meet the definition of a covered member who is an account owner in the 529 Plan. I suggested that Clifton Gunderson continue with their due diligence in researching the matter. Further, should Clifton Gunderson & Co. decide to submit a proposal to the OAG they should disclose the matter and any plan they would implement to address any independence issues.

Jodie Carey

Auditor III

2-23-11

1:55 p.m.

Edilberto C. Ortiz

Managing Partner

E.C. Ortiz

No

N/A

Phone:

Edilberto Ortiz 312-876-1900

Jodie Carey 217-558-4243

5 minutes

Discussed the firm’s interest, independence and lack of conflict of interest to conduct the financial audit of the Capital Development Board for the year ended June 30, 2011.    Noted that I will be sending the welcome letter in the near future.

Jon Fox, Auditor V

2-23-11

3:10pm

Tom Leach. Partner Sikich LLP

No

None

Phone:

Tom Leach 217-423-6000

Jon Fox 217-524-2149

10 minutes

Discussed the firm’s interest in the Office of the Secretary of State and the Illinois Literacy Foundation engagements for the fy11 audit cycle.  Tom indicated that they were interested in continuing these engagements.  We discussed Sikich’s independence and potential conflicts of interest.  We discussed the firms last and next peer review.  We discussed early work money available and start dates.  I indicated to Tom that I would send a Welcome letter about a month before the projected start date, sometime in mid-March. 

Jon Fox, Auditor V

2-23-11

3:50pm

Ed Ortiz

Managing Partner

E.C. Ortiz & Co. LLP

No

None

Phone:

Ed Ortiz 312-876-1900

Jon Fox 217-524-2149

10 minutes

Discussed the firm’s interest in the Eastern Illinois University (EIU), Illinois Finance Authority (IFA) and Council on Developmental Disabilities engagements for the fy11 audit cycle.  Ed indicated that they were interested in continuing these engagements.  We discussed if EIU would issue bonds this year.  We discussed E. C. Ortiz & Co.’s independence and potential conflicts of interest, including any non-audit services performed by the firm.  We discussed the firms last and next peer review.  We discussed early work money available and start dates.  We discussed IFA perhaps needing an additional week near year end without the auditors and its impact on the start date.  I indicated to Ed that I would send a Welcome letter about a month before the projected start date, sometime in mid-March.  Ed asked if he could contact the agency to discuss start dates and I indicated that he could.   

Jon Fox, Auditor V

2-23-11

3:10pm

Tom Leach. Partner Sikich LLP

No

None

Phone:

Tom Leach 217-423-6000

Jon Fox 217-524-2149

5 minutes

Tom called me back about our previous conversation this afternoon to discuss non-audit service Sikich is providing to several agencies.  We determined that this work would not impact their independence at the Office of the Secretary of State or the Illinois Literacy Foundation. 

Thomas Kizziah

Auditor V

2-23-11

11:30am

Jon Hoffmeister, Partner – Clifton Gunderson

No

None

Phone:

Jon Hoffmeister 630-954-8157

Thomas Kizziah 312-814-4073

5 minutes

I gave Jon a call to determine the Firm’s interest in performing the upcoming engagement for Northeastern Illinois University and to inquire as to whether the Firm was still independent.  Jon said that Clifton Gunderson was in fact interested and they remain independent.  I mentioned to Jon that we would also be performing an expanded scope information systems review and that his proposal would need to include a block of 300 hours.  I mentioned to him that we no longer pay expenses as part of our contracts and that he would need to build the expenses into his hourly rate and expenses his Firm will incur.  Finally, I told Jon that I would be sending him the Welcome Letter in approximately 6 weeks.

Thomas Kizziah

Auditor V

2-23-11

2:30pm

Cathy Baumann,

Partner, KPMG LLP

No

None

Face to Face in the Chicago Office of the Auditor General

5 minutes

Cathy was here in the Chicago Office reviewing RFP’s and we discussed the upcoming engagement for the University of Illinois.  I asked her if KPMG was still interested in performing the engagement and I asked her if the Firm was still independent.  She stated that they were interested and that the Firm was still independent.  I told her that I would be sending her a Welcome Letter soon and I also mentioned that starting in FY11 that expenses were no longer being paid as part of the contract and that the Firm’s hourly rate would need to have an expense component built into it.

Candice Long, Auditor V

2-24-11

1:40pm

Tom Leach. Partner Sikich LLP

No

None

Phone:

Tom Leach 217-423-6000

Long 217-524-5450

7 minutes

Discussed the firm’s interest in the Office of the Comptroller- Fiscal Officer engagement for the FY11 audit cycle.  Tom indicated that they were interested in continuing these engagements.  We discussed Sikich’s independence and potential conflicts of interest.  We discussed the firms last and next peer review.  We discussed early work money available and start dates.  I indicated to Tom that I would send a Welcome letter in a week or two.

Jane Clark

Statewide Single Audit Manager

2-24-11

3:30 p.m.

Cathy Baumann,

Partner

KPMG LLP

No

None

Phone

Jane Clark 217-782-0816

Cathy Baumann 312-665-8980

12 minutes

Discussed amending FY09 single audit contract.  Agreed would reduce by 12 programs minus hours built in for prior finding follow up.  Will also amend contract timetable at the same time.  I need her to send me revised dates for the timetable and a revised budget for the single audit. 

Candice Long

Audit Manager

2-25-11

8:20 am

Linda Abernethy, Partner McGladrey & Pullen, LLP

No

None

Linda Abernethy 847-413-6248

Candice Long 217-524-5450

10 minutes

Discussed the firm’s interest in the Department of Revenue engagement for the FY11 audit cycle.  Linda indicated that they were interested in continuing the engagement.  We discussed McGladrey’s independence and potential conflicts of interest.  We discussed the firms last and next peer review.  We discussed early work money available and start dates.  I indicated to Linda that I would send a Welcome letter in a month or two.

Paul Usherwood, Engagement Manager

02-24-2011, 9:00am

Nick Appelbaum, Partner, Sikich LLP

No

None

Phone:

Nick Appelbaum, 217-793-3363

5 minutes

Inquired if the firm was interested in performing the DHS engagement next year and if they had any independence issues or conflicts of interest.  Nick indicated they were planning to perform the engagement and did not have independence issues or conflicts of interest.  I indicated as the current engagement nears completion I will forward the FY 11 welcome letter and other relevant contracting information.

Gayla Rudd

Auditor V

02-28-2011

8:40 am

Chris Mower,

Partner, Crowe

Horwath, LLP

No

None

Phone

Chris Mower 217-862-2707

Gayla Rudd 217-782-8393

5 minutes

Discussed firm’s interest in performing the SIU engagement for the FY11 audit cycle and if they were independent.  Chris said they were interested and independent.  We discussed if same team would work on engagement.  She said one auditor would be replaced with one of equal experience.  We discussed the expenses for the contract would be a component built into the firm’s fixed rate.  I stated I would send the Welcome Letter in about 2 -3 weeks.

Gayla Rudd

Auditor V

02-28-2011

9:30am

Janice Romack,

Partner, West &

Company, LLC

No

None

Phone

Janice Romack 618-664-4848

Gayla Rudd 217-782-8393

5 minutes

Discussed firm’s interest in performing the General Assembly engagement for the FY11 and if they were independent.  Janice said they were interested and independent.  We discussed if same team would work on engagement.  She said the team would be the same.  We also discussed the expenses for the contract would be a component built into the firms fixed rate.  I stated I would send the Welcome Letter in about 2-3 weeks.

Christa Bull

Auditor III

 

02-24-2011

4:00 pm

Paul Pelletier, Partner, Borschnack, Pelletier, & Co.

No

Alison Schertz

Auditor IV

Phone:

Christa Bull & Alison Schertz 217-782-1009

Paul Pelletier 815-933-1771

3 minutes

Let the firm know that the manager assigned to the engagement had changed from Alison Schertz to Christa Bull.  Discussed the firm’s interest in the IMSA and IMSA Fund engagements next year and if they had any independence issues or conflicts of interest.  Paul indicated they were planning to perform the engagements and did not have independence issues or conflicts of interest.  Alison and Christa indicated to Paul that the Welcome letter would be sent out in about 2-3 weeks.

Courtney Dzierwa

Auditor IV

02-22-2011

3:35 pm

Tom Leach, Partner

Sikich, LLP

No

None

Phone:

Tom Leach 217-423-6000

Courtney Dzierwa 217-785-2108

4 minutes

Discussed the need to complete contract amendments for the DCFS engagements to reflect changes in the engagement timetables. 

Courtney Dzierwa

Auditor IV

02-26-2011

9:40 am

 

Courtney did not open the email until 2/28/2011

 

Tom Leach, Partner

 

Sikich, LLP

No

None

Email from tleach-at-sikich.com (Tom Leach) to oag11-at-mail.state.il.us (Courtney Dzierwa)

N/A

Firm emailed updated proposed updated engagement timetables for the 2010 financial audit and compliance examination of DCFS. 

Peggy Hartson

Auditor V

2-28-2011

2:00pm

Nick Appelbaum, Partner

Sikich LLP

No

Kelli Kauffman-Bruns, Manager

Sikich LLP

In person at the Sikich LLP office at 3201 W. White Oaks Dr   Spfld, IL 62704

5 minutes

Discussed the need to complete contract amendments to extend certain dates on the engagement timetable for the 6/30/10 audit of the Department of Transportation in the coming week.    Discussed engagement status to determine what the dates will need to be.

Peggy Hartson

Auditor V

2-28-2011

2:15pm

Nick Appelbaum, Partner

Sikich LLP

No

None

In person at the Sikich LLP office at 3201 W. White Oaks Dr   Spfld, IL 62704

5 minutes

Discussed the need to complete contract amendments to extend certain dates on the engagement timetables for both the FY09/10 compliance examination of the Department of Financial and Professional Regulation and the FY10 compliance examination of the Department of Insurance.